Player FM uygulamasıyla çevrimdışı Player FM !
Martin Luther and Zwingli on the Eucharist and Salvation - Protestant Agreements and Differences - CHS 133
Manage episode 238653175 series 2301034
What did Martin Luther and Ulrich Zwingli have to say about the Eucharist? In this episode, we discuss some of the major outcomes of the famous debate between Martin Luther and Ulrich Zwingli held in the city of Marburg (1529). We note that Luther was a fierce proponent of Christ’s real presence in the Eucharistic elements of bread and wine. Zwingli, however, was a staunch supporter of the symbolic nature of the Eucharist. This episode is part of our larger series on Protestant Agreements and Differences. The goal of these episode is to help Catholic Christians better understand what unites and divides Protestant Christians. The larger goal of this series is to help Catholics better understand that the differences between Protestant denominations touch the key beliefs of Protestantism as a whole, namely, salvation by faith alone and the sole authority of Scripture. Join us this week as we discuss how these two major thinkers in the early Reformation viewed the Eucharist and its bearing on salvation.
To comment on this show or provide feedback, please navigate to https://catholicheritageshow.com/episode133
The Catholic Heritage is devoted to helping Catholic Christians better understand the history, teachings and culture of their Catholic faith so that they can better love and serve Christ, the Church and their neighbors. Dr. Erik Estrada is a Catholic scholar who holds a Ph.D. from the University of Notre Dame and specializes in the history of Christianity and historical theology. He also completed a licentiate (S.T.L) in theology and patristic science at the Augustinianum Patristic Institute in Rome and a S.T.B. at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas.
If you would like to invite Dr. Estrada to speak at your next event, you can contact him at feedback@catholicheritageshow.com or 1-909-575-8035.
iOS or Android App of the CH Show Newsletter Sign-up for the CH ShowTo sign up for our podcast’s app newsletter, please navigate to: https://catholicheritageshow.com/appnewsletter/
To sign up for our podcast’s community newsletter, please navigate to: https://catholicheritageshow.com/podcastnewsletter/
To place your name on the waiting list for our future learning site, please navigate to: https://catholigheritageinstitute.com
Follow the Catholic Heritage Show on Social Media:
The Main Catholic Heritage Website: https://catholicheritage.co
The Show’s Website: https://catholicheritageshow.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/catholic.heritage.show/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Catholic-Heritage-Show-202869793834233/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/cathheritagshow
Review our Podcast
iTunes (click iTunes > Ratings and Reviews > Write a Review) and Stitcher
How to Connect with UsComment on the show below
Ask a Question via Speakpipe
Leave a voicemail for the show at 1-909-575-8035
Email via Contact Form in the Footer of the Site (audio files welcome)
YouTube
How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Old Age of a Book -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IuYpa_DOkg
What is the Canon of Scripture - Canon is a List of Books -https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rV9Uc26oPZM
How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Apostolic Origin of a Book - https://youtu.be/2EARsghZhK8
Criteria for NT Canon Point to Church Authority - https://youtu.be/OYSAemeIiNY
Criteria for Determining New Testament Canon Used by Early Church - https://youtu.be/jSI9jponGUk
Why is the Canon of Scripture Important? - https://youtu.be/xGhDSpSvnkw
# Title
72 - Early Christian Understanding of Scripture, Tradition and Church Authority - CHS 72 3/10/19
71 - Ambrose's Influence on Augustine - Doctors of the Church Series - CHS 71 3/9/19
70 - Evaluating the Secondary Sources - How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series - CHS 70 3/8/19
69 - The Life and Work of Cardinal Robert Bellarmine 1542-1621 – Doctors of the Church Series – CHS 69
68 - Identify the Genre of a Document – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS - 68 3/3/19
67 – The Problem with Secret Information about Pope Francis and the US Catholic Bishops – CHS 67 3/2/19
66 - My Recent Trip to the Civil Rights Museum in Greensboro North Carolina – CHS 66 2/28/19
65 - Identifying the Commitments of the Author – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 65 2/27/19
64 - What is the Best English Translation of the Bible in 2019? – CHS 64
63 - Did Catholicism Exist before the Emperor Constantine? – CHS 63 2/25/19
62 - The Gnostic Character of Recent Catholic Criticisms of Pope Francis - CHS 62 2/24/19
61 - Expect the Unexpected from the Sources – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 61 2/23/19
60 - How Fair is Media Coverage of Pope Francis’ Words? – CHS 60 2/22/19
59 - Objectives of the Author - How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series - CHS 59 2/21/19
58 - Catholic Disregard for the Second Vatican Council - CHS 58
55 - How Did Augustine’s Writings Survive the Vandal Invasion of North Africa – CHS 55
54 - What Are the Main Objectives When Studying Church History – CHS 54
53 - How to Locate the Primary Sources for the Study of the Catholic Heritage - CHS 53 2/8/19
52 - What Are the Primary Sources? – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 52 2/7/19
51 - Did Philo of Alexandria Reject the Deuterocanonical Books? – CHS 51 2/5/19
50 - Is Doing History an Option? – CHS 50 2/2/19
49 - Was There a Canon of Scripture in North Africa before 393? – CHS 49 1/20/19
48 - Does Quotation Equal Canonicity? Pt 3 – CHS 48 1/20/19
45 - How to Locate Primary Sources of the Catholic Heritage – CHS 45
44 - Does Quotation Equal Canonicity? Pt 1 - CHS 44 1/9/19
43 – What Have I Learned from My 2018 Work on the Catholic Heritage Show? – CHS 43 – 1/4/19
*05 - How Important Is Context for the Study of Catholic History?- CHSae 05 12/27/18
42 - What Does Incarnation Mean in Christianity 12/25/18
41 - The Canon of Scripture and Christian Unity 12/24/18
40 - Some Reflections on the Current Crisis in the Catholic Church 12/21/18
39 - What Does Heresy and Orthodoxy Mean? 12/14/18
38 - Who Were the Heresiologists? 12/11/18
37 - Jesus, the Apostles, the First-Century Church and the Canon 12/9/18
36 - The Canon of Scripture and How Christians Know Anything About Christianity 12/7/18
35 - Examples of Fraternal Correction in Church History 12/6/18
34 - The Principle of Fraternal Correction and Its Biblical Bases 12/5/18
33 - The Study of History and the Current Crisis in the Catholic Church 12/3/18
32 - Anonymity in Ancient Christian Texts 12/4/18
31 - The Muratorian Canon and Its Unique Character 12/ 2/18
30 - Jerome’s Supporters and Opponents 12/1/18
29 - Jerome and the Knowledge of Hebrew in Early Church 11/27/18
28 - Jerome, Scholarship and the Deuterocanonical Books 11/27/18
27 - Augustine, Jerome and Their Use of Each Other’s Writings - 11/23/18
26 - The Bible and the Canon – Similarities and Differences in Terminology - 11/23/18
25 - Jerome and the Old Testament Canon pt 2 – Three Perspectives on Deuterocanonical Books - 10/22/18
24 - Jerome and the Old Testament Canon pt 1 – Life, Context and Work - 10/18/18
23 - Origen’s Life, Writings, Reception and Orthodoxy - 9/25/18
22 - The Old Testament Canon Pt 2 - The Church's Selection of Books - 9/25/18
21 - The Old Testament Canon Pt 1 - Between Jewish Diversity and Gnostic Rejections - 9/17/18
20 - The Papacy and Catholic Identity - 9/13/18
19 - St. Augustine on Sinful Clergy, Donatism and the Spiritual Life - 9/6/8
18 - Church Scandals, the Papacy and Augustine of Hippo - 8/29/18
17 - Gnosticism and the Canon of Scripture - 8/20/18
16 - Conclusion for How the New Testament was Formed pt 10 - 8/14/18
15 - Papal Approval - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 9 - 8/7/18
14 - Ignatius of Loyola and His Impact - 7/31/18
13 - Conciliar Reception - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 8 - 7/26/18
12 - Patristic Reception - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 7 - 7/17/18
11 - Orthodoxy - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 6 - 7/10/18
10 - Reception of Books by the Churches - How the New Testament Was Formed pt. 5 - 7/3/18
9 - Apostolic Transfer of Books - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt 4 - 6/26/18
8 - Antiquity - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 3 - 6/22/18
7 - Apostolic Origin - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 3 - NT Canon Series pt 2 -6/19/18
6 - The Criteria Used by the Early Church to Determine the Canon of the New Testament - My Thesis - Canon of Scripture pt 4 - 6/13/18
5 - Which Criteria Did the Early Church Use to Determine the Canon of the Old Testament - Canon of Scripture pt 3 - 6/5/18
4 - When Was the Canon of the Bible Established? - Canon of Scripture pt 2 - 5/29/18
3 - What is the Canon of Scripture and Why it is Important - Canon of Scripture pt 1 - 5/23/18
2 - Ragheed Aziz Ganni (1972-2007) - Priest, Friend and Martyr - 5/18/18
1 - Introduction to the Catholic Heritage Show and Bio of Dr Erik Estrada - 5/8/18
Music provided by Pond5.
99 bölüm
Manage episode 238653175 series 2301034
What did Martin Luther and Ulrich Zwingli have to say about the Eucharist? In this episode, we discuss some of the major outcomes of the famous debate between Martin Luther and Ulrich Zwingli held in the city of Marburg (1529). We note that Luther was a fierce proponent of Christ’s real presence in the Eucharistic elements of bread and wine. Zwingli, however, was a staunch supporter of the symbolic nature of the Eucharist. This episode is part of our larger series on Protestant Agreements and Differences. The goal of these episode is to help Catholic Christians better understand what unites and divides Protestant Christians. The larger goal of this series is to help Catholics better understand that the differences between Protestant denominations touch the key beliefs of Protestantism as a whole, namely, salvation by faith alone and the sole authority of Scripture. Join us this week as we discuss how these two major thinkers in the early Reformation viewed the Eucharist and its bearing on salvation.
To comment on this show or provide feedback, please navigate to https://catholicheritageshow.com/episode133
The Catholic Heritage is devoted to helping Catholic Christians better understand the history, teachings and culture of their Catholic faith so that they can better love and serve Christ, the Church and their neighbors. Dr. Erik Estrada is a Catholic scholar who holds a Ph.D. from the University of Notre Dame and specializes in the history of Christianity and historical theology. He also completed a licentiate (S.T.L) in theology and patristic science at the Augustinianum Patristic Institute in Rome and a S.T.B. at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas.
If you would like to invite Dr. Estrada to speak at your next event, you can contact him at feedback@catholicheritageshow.com or 1-909-575-8035.
iOS or Android App of the CH Show Newsletter Sign-up for the CH ShowTo sign up for our podcast’s app newsletter, please navigate to: https://catholicheritageshow.com/appnewsletter/
To sign up for our podcast’s community newsletter, please navigate to: https://catholicheritageshow.com/podcastnewsletter/
To place your name on the waiting list for our future learning site, please navigate to: https://catholigheritageinstitute.com
Follow the Catholic Heritage Show on Social Media:
The Main Catholic Heritage Website: https://catholicheritage.co
The Show’s Website: https://catholicheritageshow.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/catholic.heritage.show/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Catholic-Heritage-Show-202869793834233/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/cathheritagshow
Review our Podcast
iTunes (click iTunes > Ratings and Reviews > Write a Review) and Stitcher
How to Connect with UsComment on the show below
Ask a Question via Speakpipe
Leave a voicemail for the show at 1-909-575-8035
Email via Contact Form in the Footer of the Site (audio files welcome)
YouTube
How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Old Age of a Book -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IuYpa_DOkg
What is the Canon of Scripture - Canon is a List of Books -https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rV9Uc26oPZM
How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Apostolic Origin of a Book - https://youtu.be/2EARsghZhK8
Criteria for NT Canon Point to Church Authority - https://youtu.be/OYSAemeIiNY
Criteria for Determining New Testament Canon Used by Early Church - https://youtu.be/jSI9jponGUk
Why is the Canon of Scripture Important? - https://youtu.be/xGhDSpSvnkw
# Title
72 - Early Christian Understanding of Scripture, Tradition and Church Authority - CHS 72 3/10/19
71 - Ambrose's Influence on Augustine - Doctors of the Church Series - CHS 71 3/9/19
70 - Evaluating the Secondary Sources - How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series - CHS 70 3/8/19
69 - The Life and Work of Cardinal Robert Bellarmine 1542-1621 – Doctors of the Church Series – CHS 69
68 - Identify the Genre of a Document – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS - 68 3/3/19
67 – The Problem with Secret Information about Pope Francis and the US Catholic Bishops – CHS 67 3/2/19
66 - My Recent Trip to the Civil Rights Museum in Greensboro North Carolina – CHS 66 2/28/19
65 - Identifying the Commitments of the Author – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 65 2/27/19
64 - What is the Best English Translation of the Bible in 2019? – CHS 64
63 - Did Catholicism Exist before the Emperor Constantine? – CHS 63 2/25/19
62 - The Gnostic Character of Recent Catholic Criticisms of Pope Francis - CHS 62 2/24/19
61 - Expect the Unexpected from the Sources – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 61 2/23/19
60 - How Fair is Media Coverage of Pope Francis’ Words? – CHS 60 2/22/19
59 - Objectives of the Author - How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series - CHS 59 2/21/19
58 - Catholic Disregard for the Second Vatican Council - CHS 58
55 - How Did Augustine’s Writings Survive the Vandal Invasion of North Africa – CHS 55
54 - What Are the Main Objectives When Studying Church History – CHS 54
53 - How to Locate the Primary Sources for the Study of the Catholic Heritage - CHS 53 2/8/19
52 - What Are the Primary Sources? – How to Study the Catholic Heritage Series – CHS 52 2/7/19
51 - Did Philo of Alexandria Reject the Deuterocanonical Books? – CHS 51 2/5/19
50 - Is Doing History an Option? – CHS 50 2/2/19
49 - Was There a Canon of Scripture in North Africa before 393? – CHS 49 1/20/19
48 - Does Quotation Equal Canonicity? Pt 3 – CHS 48 1/20/19
45 - How to Locate Primary Sources of the Catholic Heritage – CHS 45
44 - Does Quotation Equal Canonicity? Pt 1 - CHS 44 1/9/19
43 – What Have I Learned from My 2018 Work on the Catholic Heritage Show? – CHS 43 – 1/4/19
*05 - How Important Is Context for the Study of Catholic History?- CHSae 05 12/27/18
42 - What Does Incarnation Mean in Christianity 12/25/18
41 - The Canon of Scripture and Christian Unity 12/24/18
40 - Some Reflections on the Current Crisis in the Catholic Church 12/21/18
39 - What Does Heresy and Orthodoxy Mean? 12/14/18
38 - Who Were the Heresiologists? 12/11/18
37 - Jesus, the Apostles, the First-Century Church and the Canon 12/9/18
36 - The Canon of Scripture and How Christians Know Anything About Christianity 12/7/18
35 - Examples of Fraternal Correction in Church History 12/6/18
34 - The Principle of Fraternal Correction and Its Biblical Bases 12/5/18
33 - The Study of History and the Current Crisis in the Catholic Church 12/3/18
32 - Anonymity in Ancient Christian Texts 12/4/18
31 - The Muratorian Canon and Its Unique Character 12/ 2/18
30 - Jerome’s Supporters and Opponents 12/1/18
29 - Jerome and the Knowledge of Hebrew in Early Church 11/27/18
28 - Jerome, Scholarship and the Deuterocanonical Books 11/27/18
27 - Augustine, Jerome and Their Use of Each Other’s Writings - 11/23/18
26 - The Bible and the Canon – Similarities and Differences in Terminology - 11/23/18
25 - Jerome and the Old Testament Canon pt 2 – Three Perspectives on Deuterocanonical Books - 10/22/18
24 - Jerome and the Old Testament Canon pt 1 – Life, Context and Work - 10/18/18
23 - Origen’s Life, Writings, Reception and Orthodoxy - 9/25/18
22 - The Old Testament Canon Pt 2 - The Church's Selection of Books - 9/25/18
21 - The Old Testament Canon Pt 1 - Between Jewish Diversity and Gnostic Rejections - 9/17/18
20 - The Papacy and Catholic Identity - 9/13/18
19 - St. Augustine on Sinful Clergy, Donatism and the Spiritual Life - 9/6/8
18 - Church Scandals, the Papacy and Augustine of Hippo - 8/29/18
17 - Gnosticism and the Canon of Scripture - 8/20/18
16 - Conclusion for How the New Testament was Formed pt 10 - 8/14/18
15 - Papal Approval - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 9 - 8/7/18
14 - Ignatius of Loyola and His Impact - 7/31/18
13 - Conciliar Reception - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 8 - 7/26/18
12 - Patristic Reception - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 7 - 7/17/18
11 - Orthodoxy - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt. 6 - 7/10/18
10 - Reception of Books by the Churches - How the New Testament Was Formed pt. 5 - 7/3/18
9 - Apostolic Transfer of Books - How the New Testament Was Formed - pt 4 - 6/26/18
8 - Antiquity - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 3 - 6/22/18
7 - Apostolic Origin - How the New Testament Was Formed pt 3 - NT Canon Series pt 2 -6/19/18
6 - The Criteria Used by the Early Church to Determine the Canon of the New Testament - My Thesis - Canon of Scripture pt 4 - 6/13/18
5 - Which Criteria Did the Early Church Use to Determine the Canon of the Old Testament - Canon of Scripture pt 3 - 6/5/18
4 - When Was the Canon of the Bible Established? - Canon of Scripture pt 2 - 5/29/18
3 - What is the Canon of Scripture and Why it is Important - Canon of Scripture pt 1 - 5/23/18
2 - Ragheed Aziz Ganni (1972-2007) - Priest, Friend and Martyr - 5/18/18
1 - Introduction to the Catholic Heritage Show and Bio of Dr Erik Estrada - 5/8/18
Music provided by Pond5.
99 bölüm
Wszystkie odcinki
×1 The Canon of Scripture as an Unacknowledged Debt to Catholic Christianity - CHS 181 30:08
1 Competing Canons through Church History - CHS 180 33:43
1 The (In)fallibility of the Protestant Canon and Communities - CHS 179 30:49
1 Were the Books of Scripture Necessary for Every Age of Salvation History? - CHS 178 31:58
1 Were the Books of the Bible Consistently Received down through History? - CHS 177 31:12
1 The Claims to Inspiration and the Deuterocanonical Books - CHS 176 44:24
1 Providence and the Protestant Canon pt 2 - How Were the Deuterocanonical Books Received? - CHS 175 32:05
1 Providence and the Protestant Canon of Scripture pt 1 - CHS 174 37:54
1 What Does the Term Deuterocanonical Mean? - CHs 173 35:21
1 The Council of Rome (382) and the Canon of Scripture - CHS 172 28:44
1 Canon Law and the Canon of Scripture in Early Christianity - CHS 171 26:29
1 What Was Augustine's Influence over the Canon in N. Africa? - CHS 170 51:45
1 Early Christian Structures of Authority and the Closing of the Canon of Scripture - CHS 169 40:15
1 Why Did It Take so Long to Create the Canon of Scripture? - CHS 168 35:40
1 What Does the History of the Canon of Scripture Teach Us about Evaluating Competing Christian Truth Claims? – CHS 167 30:30
Player FM'e Hoş Geldiniz!
Player FM şu anda sizin için internetteki yüksek kalitedeki podcast'leri arıyor. En iyi podcast uygulaması ve Android, iPhone ve internet üzerinde çalışıyor. Aboneliklerinizi cihazlar arasında eş zamanlamak için üye olun.