What Does the History of the Canon of Scripture Teach Us about Evaluating Competing Christian Truth Claims? – CHS 167

Catholic Heritage Show w/ Dr. Erik Estrada

What does the history of the canon of Scripture teach us about discerning Christian truth claims? In this episode, I approach this question by making the general argument that Scripture by itself (sola scriptura) is incapable of establishing the nature of the canon of Scripture (i.e., the list of scriptural books). I briefly review some of the basic differences in the ways Protestant and Catholic Christians approach the question of how a Christian knows for certain which books belong to the canon of Scripture. I note that generally speaking Protestant Christians rely heavily on a certain number of criteria for determining the canon. Catholics, however, look not only to many of these same criteria but also to the Church’s authority and tradition. In this episode, we argue that Christians need the Church’s tradition and, ultimately, the Church’s authority to determine which books are indeed part of the authoritative list of scriptural books. Apart from the Church’s authority and the Church’s tradition, it becomes difficult, if not impossible, to gain certainty on the nature of the canon of Scripture. Join us this week as we discuss the relationship between the canon of Scripture and one’s ability to discern competing Christian truth claims.

To comment on this show or provide feedback, please navigate to https://catholicheritageshow.com/episode167

The Catholic Heritage is devoted to helping Catholic Christians better understand the history, teachings and culture of their Catholic faith so that they can better love and serve Christ, the Church and their neighbors. Dr. Erik Estrada is a Catholic scholar who holds a Ph.D. from the University of Notre Dame and specializes in the history of Christianity and historical theology. He also completed a licentiate (S.T.L) in theology and patristic science at the Augustinianum Patristic Institute in Rome and a S.T.B. at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas.

If you would like to provide feedback to the show, of if you have any inquiries, you can contact him at [e-mail].

iOS or Android App of the CH Show

iOS App of CHS

Android App of CHS

Newsletter Sign-up for the CH Show

To sign up for our podcast’s community newsletter, please navigate to: https://catholicheritageshow.com/podcastnewsletter/

To place your name on the waiting list for our future learning site, please navigate to: https://catholicheritage.institute/

Follow the Catholic Heritage Show on Social Media:

The Main Catholic Heritage Website: https://catholicheritage.co

The Show’s Website: https://catholicheritageshow.com

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/catholic.heritage.show/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Catholic-Heritage-Show-202869793834233/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/cathheritagshow

YouTube Channel

Review our Podcast

iTunes (click iTunes > Ratings and Reviews > Write a Review) and Stitcher

How to Connect with Us

Comment on the show below

Ask a Question via Speakpipe

Email via Contact Form in the Footer of the Site (audio files welcome)

YouTube

How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Old Age of a Book -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IuYpa_DOkg

What is the Canon of Scripture - Canon is a List of Books -https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rV9Uc26oPZM

How Were the New Testament Books Chosen? Apostolic Origin of a Book - https://youtu.be/2EARsghZhK8

Criteria for NT Canon Point to Church Authority - https://youtu.be/OYSAemeIiNY

Criteria for Determining New Testament Canon Used by Early Church - https://youtu.be/jSI9jponGUk

Why is the Canon of Scripture Important? - https://youtu.be/xGhDSpSvnkw