This week, Kaitlyn brings you yet another dark tale of a twisted cult. Are you even surprised? Listen to the story of Magdalena Solis and the Hernandez brothers who fool the village of Yerba Buena into thinking they're Inca prophets... wait... Aztec prophets? These people certainly didn't do their research before jumping into this scheme. Enjoy! . …

Tuesday! Tuesday! This week Erica takes you back to the 1700's, to tell you about a man by the name of Kondratiy Ivanovich Selivanov. Have a listen, and make sure to come back next week! Have a great week, and weekend. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousishpod Check out our website and …

This week Kaitlyn takes you on an adventure in the Way Way Back Machine, to the Roaring '20s! But this is a significantly less fun time than Gatsby had. The Divine Order of the Royal Arms of the Great Eleven (yeah, that's their full name) has some spooky and, frankly, messed up sh*t to tell you. Good luck! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.…

Happy Tuesday, this week Erica is back to tell you about the Branch Davidians, one of the most known cults known out of Waco, Texas. Have a listen, have a safe week, and hope you got the chance to see the Solar Eclipse! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousishpod Check out our website and…

This week Kaitlyn discusses a drug rehabilitation program turned "alternate society" (a.k.a. cult), Synanon. From a humble beginning to a violent and litigious end, this episode is pretty heavy. So buckle up and get ready to say Kaitlyn's favorite phrase aimed at the leader, Chuck Dederich. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousis…

Welcome to week 2 of the new season! Today Erica will be telling you about the two, known as Marshall Applewhite and Bonnie Nettles. They led some followers to believe that there was a UFO following the Comet Hale-Bopp that would take them to the Heavens. Hope you have a safe week. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Foll…

Welcome to Season 6!! We cannot wait to share some very messed up tales with you this season. To kick us off, Kaitlyn brings us a tale of a super disgusting man named Keith Raniere and his female counterpart, Nancy Salzman. This one gets pretty gnarly, so buckle up and enjoy episode one! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpo…

Hello!! Kaitlyn and Erica are throwing you a bonus episode this week! Are you excited about season 6 like we are!? Have you figured out what this season is about......perhaps......*side eye* .......anyway! Enjoy this little episode, we cannot wait to jump into this season with you guys! See you March 19th! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.…

Happy Tuesday everyone! For the season finale, you get to witness Kaitlyn in full fight or flight mode as Erica details the Clown Motel. We sure hope you enjoyed this season, and hope you look forward to the next one! Everyone stay well and safe! Until next time. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram:…

For her season finale, Kaitlyn takes on the city of New Orleans! Grab a bowl of gumbo and head on down to Bourbon Street for a tour of four haunted places! Our tour includes: Le Petit Theatre, The Old Ursuline Convent Museum, The Old Absinthe Bar, and Delphine LaLaurie's mansion. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow…

Happy Tuesday everyone, this week Erica brings you a short episode about a home in England. This home takes place of one of the most popular ghost photographs out there! I hope everyone has a great week and a good safe weekend. Remember the season is soon coming to an end, we only have 2 episode left! Crazy! We can't wait to tell you all about the …

Anyone who is familiar with the 2014 found-footage film As Above, So Below will know exactly what this episode has in store. The Paris Catacombs were intended to be a solution for an overflowing cemetery system in the late-18th Century. However, they may have gotten more than they bargained for when they moved the remains of millions of Parisians u…

I hope everyone enjoyed their holidays. This week we are back, and Erica brings you the mystery of the many room house of Sarah Winchester. I hope you enjoy this much as Kaitlyn did, and I sure loved telling it. Everyone have a safe weekend, and remember to tune in next week to hear Kaitlyn's episode! Until then! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.fa…

This week, Kaitlyn takes you to the most haunted house in... Atchison, Kansas. Although it does claim to be one of the most haunted houses in the world. You'll hear about the horrifying legend of the Sallie House's name, as well as the spooky happenings that paranormal investigators have experienced. Of course, Kaitlyn rounds out the episode with a…

Happy Tuesday everyone! Erica is bringing you another short story this week about a place that may not really be well known. It does have little info on it, but I did find it interesting! I hope all you book worms and spooky lovers enjoy this one, and maybe if you're close, take a visit! Have a great week, and safe weekend. . . . Follow us on Faceb…

We've discussed haunted dolls, haunted hospitals, haunted mansions, and even haunted islands this season. But the one thing we have yet to discuss is a haunted hotel. So that is just what we are doing today! The Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel has hosted a ton of celebrities. Just to name a few: Marilyn Monroe, Charlie Chaplin, and Clark Gable. Some of t…

Happy Tuesday, I hope everyone had a great Thanksgiving and ate a lot of yummy food! This week I bring you a short story, about a creepy doll a young girl fell in love with. Enjoy the episode! Have a good week, and a great weekend! Until next time. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousish…

This week, Kaitlyn takes you to Asheville, North Carolina to visit the Biltmore Estate. This 178,000 square foot mansion was built at the tail end of the 19th Century, so of course it is haunted. Just wait until you hear about the exceptionally terrifying pool room. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagr…

Happy Tuesday everyone, this week Erica talks about the Island of Alcatraz and the things that go on there. Would you tour the island today if you had the chance? Erica would, Kaitlyn is still on the edge. Enjoy this weeks episode, tune in next week to hear what Kaitlyn has to talk about! Enjoy your week, and stay safe . . . Follow us on Facebook: …

Today, Kaitlyn brings you a combination of her two favorite things: true crime and ghosts! We are travelling across the Midwest to Villisca, Iowa and going back to the early 1900s to learn about a brutal murder of 8 people. And, as we know, where there is tragedy there are also ghosts. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod …

HAPPY HALLOWEEN!! To celebrate the Spooky Season Finale, we decided we would each give you a story this week! This is Kaitlyn's episode, where she covers the possession of Latoya Ammons in Gary, Indiana. This one gets pretty creepy and has a lot of evidence and witnesses. Enjoy! And make sure to check out Erica's episode which has also been posted …

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! This week you get an episode from us both, how fun! I hope you are having a fun and safe Halloween. Today I bring you 2 mini paranormal stories. What do you think about a cemetery being filled with grandmas and a ghost truck stop? Have a listen, let us know what you think! Catch you guys next week! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.…

This week, Kaitlyn takes us on a short field trip down to Indianapolis! Learn about the not-so-politically-correct Central Indiana Hospital for the Insane! Built in 1848, this psychiatric hospital has a rather troubled past. Luckily for this season, "troubled past" often means GHOSTS! And that's what we're here for. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www…

Happy Tuesday everyone! Welcome back to this weeks episode where Erica tells you about another paranormal island. The island is now a state park that is filled with a bunch of activities to do! Do you dare to have a spooky night and learn more about the history? Enjoy the episode! Have a great week and safe weekend. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www…

Here it is! The promised update on the arrest made in Tupac's murder investigation! As stated in the episode, we will inform you in regular episodes what Duane Keith Davis decides to do in terms of taking a plea deal or standing trial. Should there be a trial, you already know that Kaitlyn will be all over it! This is the article Kaitlyn reads in t…

This week, Kaitlyn takes you on a terrifying journey to the Isla de las Muñecas, or the Island of the Dolls. And yes, it is as spooky as you imagine. You'll hear about the origin story for the dolls, as well as ways that the dolls haunt the people who visit the island. Good luck! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow…

Hi everyone, happy Tuesday! This week Erica tells you about a very popular ship that once sailed the ocean, and is now a hotel. This ship has so much history about it, come have a listen! And also.....HAPPY OCTOBER! Its OFFICIALLY SPOOK SPOOK season! Everyone have a great week, and a safe weekend! Until next time. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.f…

This week, Kaitlyn brings you a tale of a real life ghost ship! The mysterious nature of this case will have you scratching your head and asking many questions. One of those questions being: did this really happen? Join us this week as we get to the bottom of this strange story. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow …

Happy Tuesday everyone! I hope you are excited for this season! Tis the season to be spooky right!? This week Erica brings you info about some sisters that used to do seances....and could produce loud mysterious noises.....come check it out! We hope you enjoy! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @m…

Welcome back!! This season is going to be so much fun and very apropos for Spooky Season! For the premiere episode, Kaitlyn brings you the murderous history of Bobby Mackey's Music World in Wilder, Kentucky. And of course, where there are murders and tortures by the mafia, there will be ghosts. You will also hear about Kaitlyn's personal experience…

Happy Tuesday everyone! Welcome to this seasons finale, Erica talks about a spirit that is mostly found behind stoves or in the hearth of fireplaces. We hope you enjoyed this season, we are looking forward to season 5! We hope you enjoy your summer! We will be back in time for SPOOKY season! See you in September! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.fa…

For our triple feature finale, we decided to do "big" cryptids! So this week, Kaitlyn presents to you: Nessie! Learn about all the history and various sightings of this large creature, as well as ways she's been debunked through the decades of lore. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousis…

Happy Tuesday! Erica brings you back this week to talk to you about a very well known creature that flies through the sky. He even has his own festival, its a popular one to! I hope you enjoy the episode! Can you guess what Kaitlyn will be discussing next week? Let us know! Have a great week! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysterious…

Happy 4th of July everyone! This week, Kaitlyn discusses one of the more well-known cryptids: the Chupacabra. Typically found in Central and South America, this dog-shaped cryptid is known for attacking farm animals and draining their blood. Oh, and they're seen in the southern United States a lot too. Enjoy! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebo…

Happy Tuesday listeners! Hope everyone had a great weekend, if you were apart of the rain and storms, hope everyone is well and safe! This week Erica brings you a tale about a tentacle creature lurking in the lakes of Oklahoma. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousishpod Check out our web…

This week, Kaitlyn takes you on an adventure through the forests of Congo to learn about a massive spider cryptid. That's right! This episode is not for arachnophobes. With a leg span of up to 6 feet, this creepy crawly has a very specific way of catching its victims, er, prey... Just don't go into any forests and you'll be alright. . . . Follow us…

Tuesday again, and Erica is here to tell you about another adorable maybe not so adorable looking cryptid. Is it a hoax? Or could this creature live in the Colorado mountains to prey on the weak? Let us know what you think! We sure hope you are enjoying the season so far! Have a good week! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousish…

This week, Kaitlyn opens a big ol' jar of Nightmare Fuel for you! The "Not-Deer" is exactly what it sounds like: a deer, but not. Thought to be a creature from Navajo folklore, this terrifying cryptid will have you refusing to leave your house at night. Enjoy! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @m…

Happy Tuesday everyone! We hope you had a safe and fun memorial day weekend! Erica is back this week to tell you about a creature that has similarities to a pair of white pants.....is this creature extraterrestrial, OR is it some bird walking like a crane?? I guess we'll never know....or will we *Side eye* Hope you enjoy this weeks episode! . . . F…

This week Kaitlyn takes you on a journey to the Land Down Under! The Bunyip is a cryptid of Australian Aboriginal mythology. No one can settle on it's official description, but the stories are quite fun! The lore of what this thing does, however, is absolutely not fun. Hide your kids, hide your wives, and learn about the Bunyip! . . . Follow us on …

HELLLLLLLEEERRRRRRR! This week Erica brings you a tale about a.....not so lovely red creature from Australia. It stands about 4 ft tall, prefers to be in fig trees....and it has a HUGE stomach. Do you know what this is? I hope everyone had a good weekend, do not worry the next weekend will be here before we know it! Stay safe! Stay weird! . . . Fol…

This week, you get to learn about the cryptid that Kaitlyn is (supposedly) most like! The ahool is a cross between an ape and a bat, and the wingspan on this thing will shock you. You will also learn about some distant relatives of the ahool. Here's the quiz Kaitlyn took to find out what cryptid she is: http://thecryptidpersonalityquiz.weebly.com/ …

Happy Tuesday all you cryptid listeners! This week Erica tells you about the monster that could either be a cryptid or.....a......you will just have to take a listen and find out what else this beast could be! Enjoy your week! Thank you for listening as always! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @…

This week you get to hear about Kaitlyn's favorite cryptid! Why is the squonk Kaitlyn's favorite, you ask? Well, we think that you will see just how relatable this specific creature is. . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishpod Follow us on Instagram: @mysteriousishpod Check out our website and blog: www.mysteriousishpod.com Su…

Happy Tuesday!! This week Erica brings you on a journey about a cryptid from a small town in Massachusetts, this alien like creature became popular in 2 days when a few teenagers had only seen a glimpse. Grab your popcorn, drinks, a friend, sit back and enjoy the banter! Have a safe and great week! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/myst…

This week, Kaitlyn discusses the Goatman cryptid. There are many versions of the Goatman, but Kaitlyn is focuses on the Maryland version, with a special mention to the Texas version. There's also some psychology this episode! Because why the hell are people so scared of a goat as opposed to any other more vicious animal? Well you'll certainly learn…

This week Erica speaks about a mysterious beast that lurks in a lake in Indiana.....or used to? This beast goes by the name of Oscar, and today has a whole festival thrown for him. Listen as Kaitlyn gets her mind blown away that Indiana has their own cryptid! Thank you for listening, and let us know what you think! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.…

Happy (super belated) St. Patrick's Day! Listen, we recorded this the day after so it's only belated getting to you. Go on a journey with Kaitlyn as your guide this week! Learn about leprechauns and their origin, as well as where you can find them, how you can capture them, and what they may have in store for you. We also unlock repressed memories …

This week, Erica discusses a cryptid from Ohio: The Loveland Frogman! This 4-foot-tall, bipedal amphibian will have you scream laughing, or maybe just screaming. We're not sure if there's only one that has lived for almost 100 years, or if it's a whole species. Let us know what you think! . . . Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/mysteriousishp…

Season FOUR is finally here!! And we are so excited to talk about cryptids this season! Today, Kaitlyn tells you the tale of the Pukwudgies. These creatures are mostly seen in the "Bridgewater Triangle" in Massachusetts, but there are also some sightings in our very own Anderson, Indiana. Tune in to hear about these adorably dangerous creatures! . …